Nic Vansteenberghe & Olandria Carthen became fondly known as “Nicolandria” on Love Island USA Season 7. As the show progressed, they became one of the strongest couples. The big question is – how strong is their astrological compatibility and will they stay together for the long term?
Early Stages of the Villa
Nic and Olandria first met on Love Island USA Season 7, both entering the villa as original cast members. On Day 1, Olandria was drawn to Taylor Williams, while Nic connected with Belle-A Walker and later with Cierra Ortega. Still, their paths briefly crossed during a blindfolded kissing challenge, where a kiss hinted at chemistry between them. At the time, neither pursued it their potential connection any further.
Becoming Nicolandria
Their dynamic shifted dramatically during Casa Amor. Both Nic and Olandria ended up single after the recoupling, only to be thrown into a surprise twist: they could re-enter the villa, but only if they coupled up with each other. They agreed, and soon after shared their first real kiss. From there, their connection began to build. While Olandria admitted she still had lingering feelings for Taylor, she also continued to grow closer to Nic through late-night talks and affectionate moments.
In the final weeks of the season, Nic and Olandria became one of the villa’s most unexpected but steady couples. By the finale, they had become strong contenders and ultimately finished as runners-up, leaving Fiji with a commitment to see where things might go in the real world.
The Reunion
At the Love Island reunion on August 25, 2025, the pair confirmed they were still together. Both made it clear they were intentionally taking things slow. Nic joked about fans expecting them to be “pregnant and married” already, while Olandria explained that what she appreciated most was feeling supported and comfortable enough “to be soft” around him.
Engagement Rumors
Since the show ended, Nic and Olandria have continued to test their connection beyond the villa. They took part in a swimsuit campaign for Kulani Kinis, which took them to Greece, and have gone on several trips together. Their families have also shown support, with Olandria playfully referring to Nic’s sister as the “best mother-in-law” in a TikTok comment – fueling speculation about a possible engagement.
As of September 2025, the couple remain together. While they have not confirmed an engagement, both have made it clear that their bond is genuine, and they are choosing to move forward at their own pace. From a surprising twist at Casa Amor to a runner-up finish and now building a life beyond the show, Nic and Olandria’s story is one of Love Island’s most unexpected success stories.
Nic Vansteenberghe & Olandria Carthen – Relationship Astrology Compatibility
We asked our resident astrologer Zoe her thoughts on the couple’s astrological compatibility based on their 5 personal planets. Is Nicolandria’s compatibility as good as their nickname?
Olandria and Nic share the same Venus sign in Aries, which is a major indicator of being a power couple. They could both want similar things from their partnership and find their relationship naturally fits into place in both of their lives. They could feel like they’re on the same team, having each other’s backs and instinctively knowing what the other needs from a partner while being able to provide it. This can give their connection a solid and supportive foundation.
Her Aries Venus works very well with Nic’s Sagittarius Mars, suggesting an irresistible physical chemistry. They may naturally be drawn to physical closeness and find each other’s presence exciting, with touch only intensifying their connection. Their Mercury signs get along well too, implying ease in conversation and a strong friendship. These two were friends first, and could find they can easily connect as both friends and lovers.
Their Mars signs are opposite, which can bring competitiveness, but there’s a lot of harmony elsewhere in the connection, so this energy can help to keep things exciting. Part of how Olandria and Nic bonded was through the competitive challenges on the show, an example of how this energy can be used productively.
Their biggest concern would be Olandria’s Cancer Moon and Nic’s Aquarius Moon not seeing eye to eye. As a water Moon, Olandria could be more reserved and cautious with her emotions, wanting someone who understands her intuitively. Whereas Nic being an air Moon could feel more comfortable speaking his inner thoughts out loud, and may not instinctively relate to her more introverted side. She may have to learn how to express her emotions more verbally, while he may have to learn how to pick up on her subtle cues.
Overall they have a lot working in their favour, with strengths that outweigh their challenges.
Nic Vansteenberghe & Olandria Carthen Compatibility Score = 60%
Let us know your thoughts on Nicolandria's compatibility in the comments.
Want to see if you’re astrologically compatible with your partner or crush? Our astrology guide Are We Compatible? was created just for that! It teaches you the step-by-process so you can use it anytime. Click here to order
